Monday, March 9, 2009

What's Wrong With This Picture?


When I first heard that “Watchmen” was finally getting the greenlight and that Zack Snyder fresh off the commercial success of “300” would helm the project, ambivalence was the only feeling I could muster. “300” wasn’t a completely unpleasant way to spend a couple of hours. I respected it more for its technical accomplishments than anything else (visually, Snyder produced champagne with beer money). “Dawn of the Dead” I loathed on general principle. You don’t need to remake the best zombie movie ever IMNSHO. And the "innovative" idea to have agile zombies was just spit in George Romero's eye. It wasn’t especially original either, since Danny Boyle did it (better) in the uneven but solid “28 Days Later”. So suffice to say, I didn’t have much confidence that Snyder could transition the source material into a self-contained fully-realized piece of cinema that could stand on its own two legs. The first crop of trailers further deepened my skepticism. Would we get three hours of brutal slo-mo action sequences, perhaps another goofy slo-mo sex scene? Um, yes and yes.

I don’t think there is anything inherently “unfilmable” about "Watchmen". I read Alan Moore’s deconstructionist take on the superhero perhaps a decade ago. There is no doubt that it is a canonical text in the comic book world; it has a place reserved in the pantheon next to Frank Miller’s "The Dark Knight Returns", Gaiman’s "The Sandman" and Garth Ennis’s "Preacher". These works were the foundation of the contemporary comic book. The source material deserves every bit of respect that it's received. "Watchmen" sprawls over twelve issues and spins a wide narrative web; the book's tangents go on tangents. This might seem daunting, but the story has a very clear through-line. It is essentially a detective story told by the paranoid borderline psychotic Rorschach. It has a clearly delineated three-act structure. The book takes the scenic route to get where it's going and I wouldn't want it any other way, but the film doesn't have that luxury nor should it.


The biggest issue Snyder has is that he’s far too reverential towards the source text. Hell, Cecil DeMille took more artistic license with the Ten Commandments than Snyder does with Moore’s "Watchmen." The most glaring issue is that transferring entire swaths of dialogue from the graphic novel does not a good screenplay make. As Anthony Lane points out in his New Yorker review (his review sucks, btw; I don’t know why he or Denby for that matter even review films; they both seem like they hate movies for the most part)--you can’t have characters (even right-wing nutjobs like Rorschach) spouting lines like: “The city screams like an abattoir full of retarded children.” Yes that’s from the original text, but that doesn’t make it, you know, good.

The second major issue is that Snyder fails to capture the mood almost entirely. I’m more forgiving here, because his task was so awesome. How to capture the existential dread of the mid-eighties at the zenith of the cold war and nuclear posturing on both sides of the Iron Curtain? I remember being subjected to fear-mongering propaganda like “The Day After” which is to this day one of the scariest films I’ve ever seen. There are still images seared into my brain decades later like the poor dog digging up the kitchen floor in a vain search for food after the family had abandoned it for the basement shelter post nuclear holocaust. Damn you, Reagan!


Watchmen is set during this period and we see these scenes where tactical decisions are made and the Doomsday Clock moves closer to midnight, but we don’t feel it. We’re as detached from the ordinary citizens as Dr. Manhattan. We don’t spend enough time with the alternate world to really grasp what’s going on. One minute Dan and Laurie are having a nice dinner in a restaurant, the next people are rioting in the streets. Why? If people are rioting, why is Nixon serving a third term? Is America supposed to be a fascist nation? It’s not really clear. It's also not clear what this Watchmen group represents. We're given a couple of flashbacks to photo shoots of team pictures and a couple of Watchmen dispersing a riot, but that's all. There's no sense as to what the Watchmen meant to the world or even to each other. For the unconverted the proceedings on the screen must be terribly bewildering and/or numbingly boring. Why should anyone care about these characters? Not just the superheroes, but anyone? The film doesn't even try to answer that.

To make matters worse, the acting save for a few characters is uniformly atrocious. It’s as if they got Hollywood money to make the flick and populated it with actors that would be mediocre in a Sci-Fi Channel original movie. Malin Akerman who plays the Silk Spectre II seems lost from the very first scene and never recovers; unfortunately she gets probably the second most screen time after the superb Jackie Earle Haley (more on him later). Matthew Goode as Ozymandias comes across as the world’s most obnoxious prick as opposed to the smartest man (which might be fine in another film, but it's a complete mischaracterization of the graphic novel version). I found the Comedian’s performance to be uneven, but again the bad dialogue kneecaps him (see: Vietnam bar scene). Physically (with the exception of Goode's Ozymandias--too scrawny) the characters are three-dimensional doppelgangers of their print counerparts. Sure Patrick Wilson's Dan/Nite Owl could have been a bit paunchier, but he pulls off "middle-aged schlub" quite well. He and Jackie Earle Haley give the movie some desperately needed heart and humanity.

Some positives on the acting: Billy Crudup does about as much as one can do with Dr. Manhattan considering his performance is comprised mainly of voice over (still his few "in the flesh" bits manage to sell the tragedy of Dr. Manhattan with just a handful of scenes). Matt Frewer pops up in a minor but important role; made me smile to see good ol' Max Headroom on the big screen. Carla Cuggino as Sally Jupiter enlivens things in her few scenes, but I kept thinking why not let her play Silk Specter and just get an actual old lady to play Sally? On a related note, all the aging makeup is terrible. And the prosthetics for the actor playing Nixon are distractingly bad. No one got an inkling how bad this stuff looked from the dailies? Jeez. Anyway, Patrick Wilson as the somewhat pathetic Dan manages to create a character the audience can really invest in. Dan/Nite Owl actually comes across as a complex fully-fleshed out character as opposed to the other characters who are given a great deal of expositional baggage, but still feel rather one-dimensional.


Jackie Earl Haley as Rorschach manages to avoid that fate seemingly through force of will. As I mentioned before, he's saddled with some of the most ham-fisted dialogue in the movie, but for the most part he makes it work. He easily monopolizes the movies best scenes including the prison sequence (I still don't understand why there was a riot) and his confrontation with Dr. Manhattan at the film's end. His performance equals Ledger's turn as Joker in terms of truly capturing the essence of a well- established literary character on the screen. I'd honestly sit through the film again (on DVD) just to watch his portrayal of the schizophrenic love child of Philip Marlowe and William F. Buckley.

The word is that Zack Snyder has an extended cut that adds on at least an additional half-hour to the movie. I suspect that cut will be even worse. If I could tell the "visionary director of 300" (as the trailers dramatically intone) one thing, it'd be that what's missing from the film is not more elaborate subplots; what's missing is a vision.

A few notes: unless you’re filming an episode of The Red Shoe Diaries, a slow-motion love scene is completely risible; Tears for Fears "Everybody Wants to Rule the World" should never be used without irony in a film; gratuitous explicit violence is not inherently more real or potent than tastefully cutting away and leaving something to the imagination.

Final note: The one place Snyder does show some inventiveness is the new ending. It works. In fact it works better than Moore's original ending. If it were a better film, I'd be writing about the film's subversive commentary on religion. If it were a better film. Too bad.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

"And While You're Shaking My Right Hand, I'll Stab You With the Left"


Last night as I listened to Obama's press conference, I found myself rejoicing in the idea of having a president who might actually meet the demands of the office in both temperament and intellect.

It had been so long since the man standing behind that podium inspired confidence in me that I'd forgotten what it felt like. Obama's words were direct and his answers contained only a minimal amount of evasiveness. I was so relieved, overjoyed almost. Then I read this and the euphoria dissipated. In light of Mr. Obama's FISA vote as a senator, I guess this shouldn't be too much of a surprise.

The most egregious behavior the Bush Administration sanctioned and encouraged will continue to be a stain on this country and no amount of "looking forward" will change that. Whether or not abuses happen at the highest levels of government should not be dependent upon how honorable the people in office are. Our laws mean nothing if they don't apply to everybody and I don't think there is any hyperbole in saying that. The President failed a huge test yesterday. I doubt the MSM will cover it either. They'll be too busy dissecting last night's press conference. Meanwhile, the real news will be relegated to a blurb on page three. And so it goes...

Saturday, January 24, 2009

"Your Heartbeat Sound Like Sasquatch Feet"

"The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary."-H. L. Mencken

One of President Obama's first acts in office was to sign an Executive order to close the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay. Two days later the New York Times publishes an article about a former Gitmo detainee, Said Ali al-Shihri who reportedly rejoined Al-Qaeda and has become a "deputy leader" for "Al-Qaeda's Yemeni branch." (I use quotes in this instance because the article in no way provides any context--what constitutes the Yemeni branch? It could be a three-man terror cell for all we know. And considering that we seem to kill the "number two" Al-Qaeda operative every six months, what does it even mean to be the deputy leader?) Interesting timing, no? In the article, al-Shihri is linked to the bombing of a U.S. embassy in Yemen that occurred last September (he'd been released into Saudi custody a year prior). The Pentagon claims there are a large number of former detainees who have returned to the battlefield. Corroborating evidence of this ranges from thin to non-existent. Similar AP articles have circulated on most major news sites such as the Yahoo front page, MSNBC and CNN. The Times followed up Sunday with a roundtable of sorts talking about how this article highlights the "challenges" Obama faces in closing Gitmo. To paraphrase Donald Sutherland's character in JFK: "Who benefits?" I'm not suggesting there is a conspiracy of any kind here; what I think is obvious is that there is a concerted effort to undermine Mr. Obama's unassailable decision to close Guantanamo. It is also obvious that as it was with the Iraq War, the MSM is an all too willing accomplice in this endeavor.

There is no debate here. Guantanamo is a blight on America's international reputation; what has gone on there is demonstrably illegal and the Bush apologists' claims of how useful the facility has been have been thoroughly debunked. If the case of al-Shihri shows us anything, it is how counter-productive the policies and methods of the previous regime have proven. What outcome do we expect from imprisoning and in some cases torturing individuals for years on end without allowing even the hint of due process? We should be no more surprised at this than we are about the recidivism rate in our domestic prison system.

This is just the latest propaganda salvo from the remaining neoconservative stalwarts and hard-right Republicans in their attempts to justify and prolong the Bush policies of the years since 9/11. These are the same individuals who have demonized whistleblowers like Russell Tice for exposing the criminality of the former administration. Tice was the source for the New York Times article that detailed the illegal wiretapping program the Bush administration implemented (the same one Democratic senators Feinstein and Rockefeller gave their blessing to). He was on Countdown where he detailed more NSA abuses via illegal wiretaps. Recall this is the same illegal wiretapping activity our Congress granted the nation's largest telecommunication companies such as AT&T and Verizon immunity for this past summer (the same companies that claimed to be doing their "patriotic duty"; the same companies that lavished millions on the DNC back in August less than three months after the FISA Amendment was passed). Yet all this has been framed in the MSM as a debate about policy; the "we shouldn't criminalize policy differences"-line has become the Beltway mantra (President Obama has unfortunately if understandably echoed the same sentiment with his "we want to look forward"-stance). In the words of Bill Clinton: "This whole thing is the biggest fairy tale I've ever seen." We refuse to prosecute these injustices and thus allow those who would further perpetuate them to legitimize their position. Then these feckless demagogues use fear to galvanize the public against what is clearly just and moral.

The other insidious narrative they've tried to insert into the debate is that it will be somehow unsafe to warehouse the Gitmo detainees on American soil. Of course this is utter bull. This nation incarcerates more of its citizens than any other on the planet, so I think we're pretty good at it. Yet, straight-faced some Republican Congressional members assert Americans will somehow be endangered and subjected to higher risks of terrorist attacks should we house them stateside. Why do we keep treating these prisoners as if they're supervillains? As bad as 9/11 was, we've lost five times as many people per year to conventional domestic homicide. The ADX Florence supermax facility in Colorado currently holds the following notable convicts: Omar Abdel-Rahman, Zacarias Moussaoui, Jose Padilla, Ramzi Yousef and homegrown domestic terrorist Terry Nichols. Some of these men have been in U.S. custody for over a decade. Last time I checked we haven't had to repel any brazen rescue attempts from Osama bin Laden and his flying air fortress. I guess we should expect this level of argument from a side that thinks "24" is admissible evidence in an intellectually honest debate.

Thomas Jefferson once said: "Eternal vigilance is the price of freedom." It saddens and angers me that it is our own government employing the scare tactics and fear-mongering designed to deprive of us of that freedom which we must guard against.

Friday, January 23, 2009

OMG! They Killed Freddie! You Bastards!


So I come home from a typical long day at the office, looking for a little mindless entertainment to zone out to for an hour or so only to find my world thrown into disarray. We're watching an uninteresting NBA match-up (Lakers versus the woeful Wizards), when I ask my brother to turn to the Monsters HD channel. "Can't do it," he says. I look at him puzzled. "It's off the air. Not there anymore." Incredulous, I demand the remote and begin scanning through Comcast's HD channels. Lo and behold, he's right. It's gone. Finito. Kaput. WTF, Comcast?! I quickly head on-line to figure out what's going on only to discover the devastating truth: all the Voom HD channels were decommissioned as of Jan. 20th; Comcast announced this decision back in December, but I'd completely missed it. I hope they're happy. They just lost a customer.

Monsters HD was the only fully-dedicated horror channel, broadcasting uncut, unedited, commercial-free horror films from the black-and-white schlock of the fifties to the glorious Hammer films of the seventies and up to the mass-produced slasher franchises of the eighties and nineties. It was simply the greatest channel ever. Every film was given a beautiful 1080i full high-definition transfer. Sure they had a relatively small library, but it was rich, diverse and growing.

The station knew how to work what they had. There were werewolf marathons (The Howling and its various sequels, An American Werewolf in London, Ginger Snaps); zombie marathons (Night of the Living Dead and numerous sequels/spin-offs, Dead Alive--a gore masterpiece from Peter Jackson, Undead--a zombie flick from down under); marathons for the big Three: Friday the 13th, Halloween and A Nightmare on Elmstreet. And I watched (and re-watched) them all constantly! Thanks to Monsters HD, I probably watched Friday the 13th III-VIII a half-dozen times each. There was nothing better than coming home after a long Friday and just vegging-out on Jason Vorhees until two in the morning. I am in mourning.

To add insult to injury, to throw lye on my tear-stained cheeks, to further take a crap in my oatmeal, the geniuses at Comcast then decide to replace the Voom HD channel suite (which also included an all-Kung-fu channel, a live music performance channel, an anime channel and an oddly addictive video game channel--imagine watching someone playing PS3 on your HD TV for hours; I don't even play video games much anymore, yet it drew me in on occasion) with all premium HD channels such as HBO HD and Showtime HD. So basically I'm paying the same for less. They're crazy if they think I'm going to pony up more lucre for those stations. I've no use for HBO or Showtime in the age of Netflix. I do have a use for random horror movies 24/7.

As I understand it, the writing was on the wall for the Comcast-owned Voom HD when Dish Network unceremoniously dropped the package (they wanted a la carte, Comcast said: "all [15] or none"). Comcast couldn't justify the expense, I'm sure they'll claim, of broadcasting the package only on their cable network. I had managed to avoid getting screwed over by James Dolan unlike the millions of Knicks fans who I privately chuckled at as he drove the franchise to dizzying new lows. Now the joke's on me. How could I have ever trusted such a man? A pox upon your empire, Mr. Dolan! You've completely 'harshed' my post-inauguration euphoria.

Sunday, November 2, 2008

Saturday, October 25, 2008

Back on the Scene, Crispy and Clean



Number three on my list of "Person(s) I'd Most Like to Have a Three-hour Dinner With." New song from Bjork, Nattura. Backing 'vocals' from Thom Yorke. The phrenetic drum pattern takes a minute to get used to, but it has an almost hypnotic quality to it. I dig it. I'm honestly at the point with Bjork that if I don't like something, I believe the issue must be with me.

Hopefully this means a new album is on the horizon. Video is a fan-generated piece, an interesting amalgam of many of her previous works. I'd highly recommend checking out her full video collection, especially Bachelorette.

I think Iceland is really the lost land of Faerie.

Joe Biden in Bizarro World



I don't know how BIden manages to keep his calm talking to this creature. You're seriously going to ask the question: "Is Barack Obama a Marxist?"? DIAF. Seriously, DIAF.